Sales and marketing news, data and thoughts for people who make things.

Industry edition · Content and Video

Six of 10 equipment ROI calculators showed a result without asking for an email

We tested 10 ROI calculators on the websites of nine machinery and automation sellers on Nov. 3, 2026. Six of the 10 showed a payback, savings or earnings figure without asking for contact details. The other four asked for at least an email address first, two of them before showing a result on the page and two before letting visitors download the calculator.

An operator in safety glasses lowers an aluminum block into the vise of an open, stopped vertical machining center while an engineer in safety glasses watches from a step behind.
An engineer watching an operator load a part into a vertical machining center.

When a plant engineer asks a machinery seller to justify the machine before talking price, an equipment ROI (return on investment) calculator on the website can do the first pass. The 10 we tried cover cobot palletizing and machine tending cells, stretch wrappers, packaging machinery, an air compressor, a compressed air product and a fiber laser. The six that showed a number without a form all opened with their defaults already filled in.

From what the six open tools do well, a machinery seller should put the calculator on the page, ungated, with realistic defaults and the formula in view. An option to email or print the result lets the engineer forward the number to the rest of the buying committee, and the contact form belongs after the result, as an offer of a site visit or a scoped quote. A payback figure may be the only budget number a buyer finds on the site, since just one of the 13 machinery makers’ homepages in our study of machine searches linked to a published starting price.

What did 10 equipment ROI calculators ask for?

The set began as eight calculators, most of them for palletizing, stretch wrap and packaging. We widened it with two more, from the compressed air products maker EXAIR and the machine tool seller RMT. We opened each tool in a browser on Nov. 3, 2026 and checked whether a result appeared without a name or email. Where a form stood before the result, we recorded which fields it required and did not submit it. Using the page code, we counted the fields a buyer can set, then confirmed each count on screen. Ceccato’s estimator has no fields in its page code, so we counted the adjustable values on its main screen.

We could count the fields on six tools, five of the six open ones plus Industrial Packaging’s gated stretch wrapper calculator, and the counts ranged from four to 20. EXAIR’s air savings calculator, for replacing a blowoff with one of its compressed air products, asks for four: current air consumption, the product’s consumption, the product’s cost and the cost of compressed air. With its defaults of 300 and 25 standard cubic feet per minute, a $500 product and air at $0.25 per 1,000 cubic feet, it opened on Nov. 3, 2026 at a payback of 5.1 days. Gertex Solutions’ stretch wrapper calculator asks for 20, covering throughput, labor, film, pre-stretch, four optional time-saving features, damage reduction and financing. The other counts were 10 on Ceccato’s compressor Payback Estimator, 12 on Absolute Machine Tools’ cobot savings calculator, and 15 each on OPTEL Group’s cobot palletizer calculator and Industrial Packaging’s stretch wrapper calculator.

Fig. 01Ten equipment ROI calculators: what each asks for and what a buyer gets
Seller and machineSeller typeFields we countedResult without contact detailsBuyer gives firstMath shown
Robotiq, cobot palletizingAutomation supplierNot visible (download)NoFirst and last name, email, phone, countryList of factors only
Viking Masek, packaging machineryMachine makerNot visible (download)NoEmail, phone, packaging interest, countryFormula and example in a 2023 blog post
Industrial Packaging, stretch wrapperDistributor15NoFirst and last name, work email, countryNone before the form
Industrial Packaging, packaging machineryDistributorNot visible (first screen asks for contact details)NoFirst and last name, business emailNone before the form
OPTEL Group, cobot palletizerAutomation supplier15YesNothing (emailed report optional)Formula under the result and benchmarks
Absolute Machine Tools, cobot machine tendingMachine tool and cobot distributor12YesNothing (emailed results optional)Each field says how it enters the math
Gertex Solutions, stretch wrapperDistributor20YesNothingSavings formula and annual breakdown
Ceccato, air compressorMachine maker10YesNothingCost comparison table
EXAIR, compressed air productsCompressed air products maker4YesNothingAir and dollar savings by minute, hour, day and year
RMT, fiber laserMachine tool sellerNot counted (embedded spreadsheet)YesNothingEvery row of the spreadsheet; no payback figure

Fields we counted are the values a buyer can set on the page, counted from the page code and checked on screen, except Ceccato's estimator, which was counted on screen, main screen only; we could not count fields inside a download or behind a contact form. Result without contact details means a payback, savings or earnings figure appeared on the page with no name or email entered. Seller types are as each site describes itself. Pages checked in a browser Nov. 3, 2026; no form was submitted. Source: Our analysis of 10 calculator pages, checked Nov. 3, 2026.

Which ones show the payback, and which ones ask for a name first?

Six of the 10 returned a number with no contact details. OPTEL’s calculator opened with a payback of 0.9 years and a net annual benefit of $206,000 on its default inputs, and it updates as each field changes. Absolute’s calculator showed $50,040 in estimated annual net savings and an 11.2-month payback on its defaults, and the payback changed to 9.0 months when we raised the hourly wage from $25 to $30. Gertex opened at $37,601 in annual savings and a seven-month payback. OPTEL and Absolute both offer to email the result, and neither requires it.

Two of the four gated tools, Robotiq’s Lean Robotics ROI Calculator and Viking Masek’s Packaging Equipment ROI Calculator, are downloads behind forms that require email, phone and country, and Robotiq’s form adds first and last name while Viking Masek’s adds a packaging interest area. Industrial Packaging’s stretch wrapper page, the third gated tool, shows all 15 fields, but the button that returns the result, “Calculate My Savings,” is the submit button of a contact form that requires first and last name, work email and country. The fourth, Industrial Packaging’s Ultimate ROI Calculator for packaging machinery, asks for name and business email on its first screen, before any production question.

Viking Masek gates its calculator download but explains the math openly in a June 1, 2023 blog post on calculating packaging machine ROI, which shows both formulas and works an example: a $200,000 system with a $150,000 net annual benefit gives a 75% return on investment and pays back in 1.3 years.

Should the result sit behind a form?

We would put the payback on the page and the form after it. A gated result gives the seller a lead, but the plant engineer has to hand over contact details before seeing any number to show the financial controller or the plant manager. Our piece on selling capital equipment to a buying committee covers who reads that number next.

The open tools still collect leads through offers on the same page, such as the “Get Your Custom Automation Quote” button directly under Absolute’s result, a free site assessment in OPTEL’s page header and a separate contact form below Ceccato’s estimator.

Showing the formula matters as much as showing the result, because the buyer’s finance team will check the assumptions. OPTEL shows its formula, “(system cost ÷ cobot efficiency) ÷ net annual benefit,” directly under the result. Its Cobot ROI Blueprint page walks the same math step by step, with a $172,000 system and $105,000 in manual labor paying back in 0.87 years. The page divides labor by an 80% human efficiency and then multiplies that figure by a factor of 1.60, which is 1 plus the 35% productivity gain and the 25% damage reduction, so a finance reviewer can question each assumption. Absolute explains each field beside its input. The note on cobot lifetime reads “Divides Total Upfront Investment to get an ‘annualized’ equipment cost,” and the calculator subtracts that annual share from savings before it calculates payback. By our arithmetic, the default payback of 11.2 months would be about 9.4 months without that deduction.

Ceccato’s estimator sits on its international English page, which its site lists for US visitors. On Nov. 3, 2026 the estimator opened in euros, and it did the same in a fresh browser set to US English. On its defaults, the comparison table showed savings of minus 49,000 euros over a 10-year evaluation period and a payback of 33.3 years, so a buyer who changes nothing sees a compressor that does not pay back within that period.

RMT’s fiber laser calculator compares a competitor CO2 laser with its own fiber lasers in an embedded spreadsheet and reports after-tax income per year and total earnings at the end of the loan term, with no payback period.

What should an equipment ROI calculator ask for?

We would ask for the numbers a plant engineer already knows or can get from the floor in a day, prefill each with a stated default, and leave the rest as optional fields. The questions Absolute lists for its automation engineers, such as cycle time, operator pay, benefits cost and current throughput, are a good starting list for a machine-tending cell.

Fig. 02 lists the fields we would put on a machinery payback calculator. Its 14 rows hold 16 fields, more than EXAIR’s four and fewer than Gertex’s 20, and each row shows a default or is marked optional, so the buyer can change any of them on screen.

Fig. 02Fields for a machinery payback calculator
FieldTypeSensible default
Machine priceDollarsYour typical configured price, rounded
Installation, integration and riggingDollarsA stated percentage of price, editable
Training and startup downtimeDollarsA stated figure, editable
Operators per shift on the task todayNumber1
Shifts per dayNumber2
Hours per shift and days per yearNumber8 hours, 250 days
Hourly wageDollarsYour region's typical operator wage, editable
Benefits and payroll burdenPercent of wage30%
Operators per shift after the machineNumber0 or 1
Throughput today and with the machineUnits per hourBlank, optional
Scrap, rework or damage savedDollars per year0, optional
Maintenance and energyDollars per yearA stated percentage of price
Consumables (film, tooling, gas)Dollars per year0, optional
FinancingMonthly paymentBlank, optional

Our recommended field list. Show every default on screen, put the formula under the result, and let the buyer email, print or download the result without filling in a form. Source: Our recommendation, drawn from the 10 calculators reviewed Nov. 3, 2026.

Net annual benefit is labor saved plus other savings minus new operating costs, and payback is total installed cost divided by net annual benefit. Fig. 03 applies that math to made-up round numbers, labeled as an example.

Fig. 03Worked example: a machine that replaces one operator on each of two shifts
ItemCalculationAmount
Total installed cost$200,000 machine + $30,000 installation and training$230,000
Labor saved$39 an hour fully burdened × 2,000 hours × 2 shifts$156,000
Scrap savedExample figure$8,000
Maintenance and energyExample figureminus $10,000
Net annual benefit$156,000 + $8,000 − $10,000$154,000
Payback$230,000 ÷ $154,0001.49 years (about 18 months)

Example only. The numbers are made up and round, the $39 rate is a $30 wage with 30% burden, and 2,000 hours is the Fig. 02 default of 8 hours a day for 250 days. Source: Our example.

Put a note under the result saying what the calculator leaves out, such as taxes, depreciation, financing cost and the value of added capacity. Our trade show ROI worksheet uses the same approach of showing every step of the math.

In your industry: automation and cobot sellers

Three of the 10 tools, from Robotiq, OPTEL and Absolute, are for cobot cells, where the payback rests on labor hours moved off a person, so the efficiency and coverage assumptions drive the result. OPTEL publishes its benchmarks next to the inputs (80 to 85% human efficiency, 90 to 95% cobot efficiency), and Absolute applies a coverage percentage of 100%, 90% or 75% depending on the task complexity the buyer picks. If you sell automation, show those assumptions next to the inputs where the buyer can change them. Our piece on selling automation to plant managers covers what that audience asks for after the payback.

What to do before you build one

  1. Enter your sales team’s last five quotes into a spreadsheet version of the Fig. 02 fields, and set the defaults from the median of those deals.
  2. Build the calculator on the page, ungated, and show the payback, the net annual benefit and the formula together.
  3. Add “email me this result” and a button to print the result next to it, with the email field optional and asking for nothing else.
  4. Put the contact offer under the result, as a site visit, an application review or a scoped quote.
  5. Open the calculator with no changes and read the first result a buyer sees. If the default case shows a loss or a payback longer than the machine’s life, change the defaults.
  6. Track how many people reach a result and how many of them ask for the quote, so the form’s placement is judged on quotes requested.

Sources

  1. EXAIR, Air Savings Calculator USD (run Nov. 3, 2026)
  2. Gertex Solutions, Stretch Wrapper ROI / Payback Calculator (run Nov. 3, 2026)
  3. Ceccato, Calculate your payback on compressor (international English page, listed for en-us) (run Nov. 3, 2026; the estimator is served from bp-ct-hosting.atlascopco.com)
  4. Absolute Machine Tools, Cobot Automation Savings Calculator on the Machine Tool Automation page (run Nov. 3, 2026)
  5. Absolute Machine Tools, How to Calculate ROI to Justify a Collaborative Robot, June 12, 2025 (read Nov. 3, 2026)
  6. OPTEL Group, Cobot Palletizer ROI Calculator (run Nov. 3, 2026)
  7. OPTEL Group, Cobot ROI Blueprint (read Nov. 3, 2026)
  8. Industrial Packaging, Stretch Wrapper ROI Calculator (checked Nov. 3, 2026)
  9. Industrial Packaging, The Ultimate ROI Calculator for Packaging Machinery (checked Nov. 3, 2026; intro page https://www.industrialpackaging.com/ultimate-packaging-machinery-roi-calculator)
  10. Robotiq, Lean Robotics ROI Calculator (checked Nov. 3, 2026)
  11. Viking Masek, Packaging Equipment ROI Calculator (checked Nov. 3, 2026)
  12. Viking Masek, How to calculate the ROI on a potential packaging machine purchase, June 1, 2023 (read Nov. 3, 2026)
  13. RMT (Revolution Machine Tools), Laser Cost Calculator (run Nov. 3, 2026)
  14. Plant to Pipeline, Selling capital equipment to a B2B buying committee
  15. Plant to Pipeline, Selling automation to manufacturers after a year of AI pilots
  16. Plant to Pipeline, Trade show marketing that pays back: a 2027 ROI worksheet

See an error? Email editor@planttopipeline.com with what is wrong. We fix errors and log them on the corrections page.

Filed under

Filed under

The Tuesday issue

One idea, one number and one example from a company like yours. Every Tuesday, under five minutes.

We use your email to send our newsletter and marketing emails. Unsubscribe anytime. Read our privacy policy.